Vietnam Investment Plunges in Cambodia, Sparking Concerns

School of Vice: 

I wouldn't read too much into this investment statistics. The Vietnamese - even more so than the Chinese - have sucked and soaked up all the nutrients out of this small rural country, and the ecological and environment skeletons that she has now become is very much thanks to Vietnam's so-called 'economic co-operation' and intervention long before the Chinese came into the picture and equation. 

Most Cambodians are still in the dark over the actual terms of the vast amount of state and communal lands leased to Vietnam through its state-controlled 'companies' and ventures, specifically the rent rate levied on them annually. I don't have the precise figures to hand, but it is known to be pretty dismally ridiculous or generous - whichever way one wishes to look at them. If Hun Sen himself has until now been ignorant of the extent of the deforestation and other related social abuses linked to the granting of these 'ELCs', then it is obvious that he must have been falling asleep on the job as 'PM', or never ventured far outside and beyond the capital city of Phnom Penh? 

What can we make of Hanoi's part in this unprecedented environmental hemorrhage and devastation or willing execution and hatchet job? Is it inevitable that economic policies and practices must take their own course whatever their collateral damages to and consequences for human lives and their environment? Is social ethics a hindrance to 'development' and market growth that this moral issue must be kept well out of the economic process? Are these conscious harms the real signs and price of the "fraternal" relationship between any two nations? Do Cambodian lives matter also? 

As for aiding a thoroughly corrupt, incompetent and brutal regime that this one is, why should the Vietnamese keep doing this too when the Chinese are only too eager to throw in the cash? And speaking of cash, the Chinese are not [or have not been] the only acting patron and benefactor either. The West and other affluent Asia-Pacific Rim countries have been doing likewise to help keep the regime afloat - politically and 'economically'. Yet and despite all the billions in economic aid and assistance, millions of Cambodians of working age are still looking to take up work abroad to support themselves and their families, while their ruling counterparts look to overseas to buy trophy mansions and estates, as well as indulging in luxury shopping sprees. 

>>>  

05 October 2016

Luke Hunt

FILE - People wait for garment workers to leave a factory in a suburb of Phnom Penh.

PHNOM PENH — 

Relations between Cambodia and Vietnam have been sorely tested in recent years by border disputes and their starkly different positions on Beijing's maritime ambitions in the South China Sea. Now those ties are being aggravated by a dramatic slump in foreign investment.

Investment from Vietnam in free fall

Foreign direct investment (FDI) from Vietnam into Cambodia fell to almost zero in the first half of this year, a revelation that stunned many in business, government and civil society.

No comparable figures were given by the Council for the Development of Cambodia (CDC), but Vietnam had ranked fifth among Cambodia's investors after China, South Korea, the European Union and Malaysia.

Cambodia Vietnam border tension

The collapse also came as local reports said Cambodia's foreign ministry had sent more than 20 diplomatic notes complaining that the Vietnamese had not halted the construction of buildings within a designated no man's land along their common border.

Border issues and investment also topped the agenda as high-level delegations from Phnom Penh and Hanoi met here over the past week, but no joint statements were released, which analysts said indicated a lack of agreement.

“The Vietnamese and the Cambodians are sort of in polar positions,” said Keith Loveard, a regional security analyst with Concord Consulting.

He said Vietnam was increasingly the place to go for FDI and it “is picking up an awful lot of Western business”, partly because of its proximity to the Chinese market and as China becomes more expensive, Vietnam is becoming more attractive.

China, Cambodia become closer

“On the other hand Cambodia is increasingly locked into this Chinese embrace and it finds itself rather at odds, with Laos perhaps sort of sitting quietly as always in the background, as very much an outlier within ASEAN,” Loveard added.

Analysts had warned Cambodia could face 'pay back' from other members of ASEAN after Phnom Penh backed Chinese maritime claims across islands and waters in the South China Sea, which are also claimed in part by Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, The Philippines and Vietnam.

Different approach to maritime disputes

Beijing wants those disputes resolved on a bilateral level with each, individual claimant.

But Vietnam has led an ASEAN push to told hold talks on a multilateral basis – opposed by Cambodia at China's behest. In return, Beijing became Cambodia's largest benefactor putting at risk a trade relationship between Vietnam and Cambodia worth billions of dollars.

FILE - Cambodian Defense Minister Tea Banh, second left, shakes hands with a Chinese army adviser during a graduation ceremony at the Army Institute in Kampong Speu province. Cambodia has backed Chinese maritime claims across islands and waters in the South China Sea.

At the latest ASEAN summit in Laos in early September, Cambodian diplomacy succeeded in watering down an ASEAN communique aimed at tackling Chinese claims, a move that aggravated some of the other members of the 10-nation ASEAN trade bloc.

“It does not matter if we do not have any Vietnamese investment coming in, though we are a bit baffled,” CDC Deputy Secretary-General, Chea Vuthy, told a recent business forum. “We hope business relations will improve and there will be some investment projects in the second half of the year.”

Business relations have been robust in the past

According to the CDC, bilateral trade in 2015 hit $3.37 billion, with Cambodian exports to Vietnam amounting to $954 million and imports at $2.41 billion.

The figures were released as a series of meetings got underway led by Nguyen Thi Kim Ngan, Chairwoman of the Vietnamese National Assembly, who led a 72-member delegation to Phnom Penh.

As they ended, the Cambodians tried to reassure reporters that both countries would work to 'maintain their close relationship' amid competition from world superpowers, widely interpreted as a veiled reference to their differences over Chinese maritime claims.

But Cambodian spokesman Keo Piseth also noted the Vietnamese delegation had aired concerns about investing near their shared, 1,228-kilometer land border, where demarcation disputes have persisted in recent years, and at times have turned ugly.

“Vietnam also asked Cambodia to support and protect legal Vietnamese companies that are investing in Cambodia,” he said.

Vietnamese delegates remained tight-lipped about the meetings, declining to comment.

Instead, its official media focused on Ngan's meetings with Cambodian King Norodom Sihamoni and Say Chhum, President of the Cambodian Senate, reporting that both sides were hopeful of settling the remaining issues along their shared land border.

Problems with Vietnamese companies in Cambodia

Analysts and civil rights advocates said problems persisted with Vietnamese companies operating in Cambodia, which ignored government policies and had not met their corporate obligations with the local communities.

This had led to protests over issues ranging from land grabbing to control over water and might have contributed to the sharp fall in FDI coming from Vietnam.

“For Vietnam, from our experience, we don't have any common standard between the civil society and the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce, so we hope in the future we can work together and to develop the common standards and common guidelines that encourage the solving of people issues,” said Tek Vannara, the Executive Director of NGO-Forum.