Editorial by Khmer Circle:
The acclaimed historian and his alleged personal traits as highlighted in red below would have certainly been a cause for a much shorter life span had any of those characteristics been directed or utilised instead against the ruling status quo throughout Indochina, and more specifically, his beloved CPP or its previous incarnation: the PRK. See the late Dr Kem Ley and many others who had really trodden the path of "Truth" and or been outspoken against social injustice in the Kingdom.
It was Vickery and buddies who spawned this notion that Cambodian nationalist movements and their innate sentiments are nothing more or less than outpourings of irrational, racist xenophobia which must not be allowed to gain any degree of meaningful political momentum or relevance at any cost. External foreign interference [armed intervention and colonial domination] and hegemony vis a vis Cambodia's domestic affairs are premised under these theoretical presumptions, and so are Hun Sen's incessant threats that war and violence would break out if and when the ruling CPP loses power - democratically or otherwise.
One of Vickery's swipes against the old Cambodian regimes is that their ruling personalities, from Sihanouk to Lon Nol, had been surrounded by "sycophants" and yes-men. It is conspicuously ironic therefore that Vickery himself, for all his supposed ‘fierce devotion to Truth and facts’, had never permitted himself the necessary courage to condemn this very same trait and tendency that his beloved CPP has been indulging as part of its deliberate social patronage network building and consolidation throughout his life time.
Vickery had even called on the Phnom Penh regime to ‘review’ the visa of overseas Khmers, citing an ancient Greek insight [Aristotle’s?] about how returning exiles are being out of touch with life and realities in their native country!
Today, there are a number of these dual citizenship holding Cambodians in the country, some of whom are attached to civil society groups; some are to the ruling administration in some subordinate capacities. But most striking, of those who are aligned with the main political opposition as well as a minority who speak out against the regime, several have found to their personal cost as a consequence of Vickery’s wish being fulfilled as they are denied safety or entry into their home land or are being made to languish in prison; all for having committed regime-defined crimes...
<<<>>>
Reader: His death should be ignored and not to be celebrated. He and late wife have lived and supported communist ideology dictatorship, ignoring the other side of sufferings, who endeavor to earn their liberty and democracy. He was a bad ass if not worse than Allen Meyers who unjustly put down the democrats with unsavory appetite of political character assassinations.
Funeral services end today for the late prolific academic Michael Vickery, who made significant contributions to the study of Cambodia’s history. Vickery died on Thursday in Battambang province where he was cremated last night. Michael Karnavas
Cambodia bid farewell to a giant of Southeast Asian scholarship on Thursday with the death of the American historian Michael Vickery in Battambang, where his funeral ends today. He was 86.
Colleagues, friends and family remembered him for his fierce intellect, unapologetic devotion to the truth, encyclopaedic memory and mastery of over a dozen languages, many of which – it was said – he picked up through various romances.
“On the pillow,” as Vickery’s close friend Olivier de Bernon put it. De Bernon, a professor at the French School of the Far East, recalled Vickery as a prodigious debater who would entertain lively wine-fuelled conversations.
“He had a unique talent for polemics,” he said.
Born on April 1, 1931, in Billings, Montana, Vickery came from modest means, but his family’s progressive values shaped Vickery’s scholarship, which is often viewed as falling into Marxist schools of thought – although, de Bernon noted, “he was not a communist”.
Vickery taught English, lectured and studied around the world, but much of his life was spent in Thailand and Cambodia. Starting from 1960 to 1964 as an English teacher at the Lycée de Kampong Thom, he would count among his students Kaing Guek Eav, later known as Duch, the infamous S-21 prison director. After doctoral studies at Yale University in 1977, he established himself as an expert on Cambodia and the region. His dissertation, de Bernon said, was remarkable as a rigorous analytical comparison of the Thai and Cambodian Royal Chronicles.
An old portrait of the historian Michael Theodore Vickery, who passed away on Thursday in Battambang. Photo supplied
Pre-Angkorian history drew Vickery’s focus, culminating in the book Society, Economics, and Politics in Pre-Angkor Cambodia. When he died, Vickery was writing a companion book on Angkorian Cambodia. Noting Vickery was a scholar of Cambodian history up through the present, de Bernon said “the spectrum of his interests was very unique”, adding that Vickery could read ancient texts “like reading a newspaper”.
His principal scholarly contribution, de Bernon said, was that he was the first to have methodically described the social structures of ancient Cambodia.
But Vickery “was blunt”, de Bernon recalled.
Indeed, in frequent editorials in The Post he took aim at politicians, scholars, journalists and the paper itself. In one 2001 letter, he labelled an article “the filthiest piece of pseudo-journalistic hack work and character assassination I have seen in years”, and accused then-owner Michael Hayes of selling his soul.
Among those he sparred with was fellow historian David Chandler, who yesterday said “I miss him, regardless of his hostility to my work. Very few scholars of Cambodia have bequeathed work of such a consistently high value . . . His death leaves an enormous gap in my life and in the lives of many others.”
Prolific academic Michael Vickery, seen inspecting a negative film strip, passed away on Thursday in Battambang province. Photo supplied
Cambodian archaeologist Chin Chanratana recalled Vickery as among his favourite professors, noting a firm but compassionate approach towards students. “I loved him from the bottom of my heart,” he said, noting that it was sad Vickery died in relative poverty.
At home, his foster daughter Amema “Mimi” Saeju, 36, recalled a warm animal-lover who raised her with his later-life partner Otome Klein, 87, a Dutch anthropologist.
“When it comes to work it was his responsibility to be extreme sometimes . . . [but] in the house he was quite a reasonable person,” she said. But above all she recalled his openness and candour about sex and relationships. “He loved to talk about women,” she said with a laugh.
Later, Vickery consulted with the late Ieng Sary’s defence at the Khmer Rouge tribunal. Ieng Sary defender Michael Karnavas, a friend for 22 years, said in an email that Vickery was “a fierce critic of sloppy critical analysis . . . a great conversationalist with a bent for provoking with off-colour and politically incorrect remarks. Yet he was a gentle and generous soul, always ready to lend an ear and share his encyclopaedic knowledge.”
“Michael was quirky and cantankerous. He could drive you crazy with his politics,” he said.
Khmer Rouge tribunal defence lawyer Michael Karnavas walks with Michael Vickery at the ECCC during the case against the late Ieng Sary. Photo supplied
Most relevant to the trials was Vickery’s rejection of what he called the “Standard Total View”: the body of widely accepted – and, in his view, insufficiently rigorous – scholarship that suggested the Khmer Rouge was a monolithic entity. Vickery set a high bar for analysing historical facts, and challenged the popular version of Khmer Rouge history on such issues as death totals, sexual violence and how fragmented the regime was.
In all, Karnavas noted, “Michael Vickery was a Cambodian institution, an old hand, and to many, a legend.”
But for many, Vickery’s convictions that he would work only to sustain himself, his disdain for materialism and his refusal to be tenured at a university in order to maintain the independence of his voice ultimately caught up to him. He grew reliant upon the charity of his friends and relatives for support.
In his final months, Vickery lived with his brother-in-law, Meas Savuth, 72, who said that his dying wish was to have a Cambodian funeral. “He wanted to die in Cambodia,” he said, noting that many former students travelled from afar to pay their respects over the weekend.
Vickery died of a heart attack after a long period of illness at 11am on June 29. He is survived by his adoptive daughter Mimi, his partner Otome Klein, his in-laws and his ex-wife Angina Vickery, and their daughter Angelina.
8 comments:
Starting from 1960 to 1964 as an English teacher at the Lycée de Kampong Thom?
I don’t remember in what year the English class at the Lycée started.
In 1962 I was taught English 2 hours/week starting in 8th grade (classe de 5ème), and it was also the year they introduced the Russian language course as well.
Students could choose either English or Russian but not both.
My Lycée was big; there were 14 classrooms for the 8th graders alone. There were only 2 classrooms for the 8th graders who chose Russian.
They taught us English till 12th grade (classe de première), they did not teach us English at the final year of high school (classe de terminale).
Note: Back then it took 13 years to get the high diploma (BAC2).
Karl Marx was 100 times more scholar than this guy.
If telling the truth is rude then you should respect the lies.
6:32 am,
Lycee Kompong Thom 1960-1964. Classe de 6eme has 5 classrooms 6A-6E. Classe de 5eme has 8 (5A-5H) because of those transferred from the private schools and/or areas such as Taing Kauk, Kompong Thmar etc, classe de 4eme 4A-4E, and 3eme 3A-3E. Classe de seconde 1, and classe de 1ere 1 in just one building. D.E.S.P.C (diplome d'etude secondaire du premier cycle) Exam existed and took place in Lycee Komgpong Thom in 1964. No BAC I exam could took place in Lycee Kompong Thom yet between 1965-1966. They either have to go to Lycee Siemreap or Lycee Sihanouk or Phnom Penh to take the exam. Kompong Thom has 2 private schools: Bompenh Vichea, and Serei Sophorn...Kek Eav used to teach there privatetly as well. a few french professors such as Cliozo, dubois, Mme Minard and Mercier, Luzzy etc...Kim Tuot is the "Proviseur" of Lycee Kompong Thom at that time. The head of library is Teu So. Among cambodian teachers were just to name a few: Kang Saran, Yin Kim Tech, Hem Se, Chhriss, Mam Nay, professeur Science Naturelle (the guy with skin cancer (ស្រែង) being tried along with Kek Eav) English professor - a guy by the name of LY ( studied in the US just for 6 months). Hem Se, although taught math, was assigned to teach English as well. One student that studied Russian by he name of Uon Kdompea ended up studying in Russia as well later...There was one Indian guy that taught French also at that time...BUT THERE WAS NO VICKERY NAME ANYWHERE there....
And Khmerization/Khemarakyeankam (ខេមរយានកម្ម) took place in 1965.
1960-1964, the period where Maso Tse Toung little red book had been passed around almost freely in khmer "college" and "Lycee". The haves and have nots treat each other like piece of shit, look at each other from head to toes. The rest is history. Kompong Thom was one hot spot for the commies...
5:51 pm
You have a very good memory, my friend.
6:09 pm
I agree with you about the haves and have nots, but if you were at the top 3 of the class they respected you.
I attended Kampong Cham high school. I had many French teachers not just for the French classes, some taught us math, physics, chemistry. I only remember 3 French teachers: Mr. Nandillon taught French at 6, Mr. Sand, who lost his left forearm in ww2, taught French at 3, Mr. Hubin taught physics in classe de terminale serie math. My 1st English teacher was an Indian man from Pondicherry by the name of Mr. Lesel.
For the 1st few years of my study there the principal was Mr. Meas Dim, and then they moved him to Lycee Sisowath.
There were at least 4 private high schools as far as I remember, but I only remember 3 school names: serey sophoan, serey roth and preah keo.
I remember one incident well, there was a French math teacher at 4, who liked to wear short and he was a mean son of the gun. There was a student who liked to joke around. Each classroom had a raised wooden platform (estrade) at the front for the teachers to sit and walk on. In order to get to his table and bench, the funny student had to walk in front of the sitting teacher, and every time he walked in front the teacher he bowed and pretended to look at the teacher’s crotch. The rest of the class quietly chuckled. The silent chuckles irritated that French math teacher. One day the teacher called that student to discipline him outside the classroom about joking around with him, but the student responded that he did not mean to disrespect him; it is a Khmer custom to bow like he did when walking in front of a respectful person.
Hun Sen and the CPP can now rewrite history more to their liking.
6:09 am
Sure, HS paid an author Julie B. Mehta to cook up his biography and as you can see there are only 3 customers who review the book and they all give it a 1 star. If there is zero star in the scale, the book would earn that for sure. And HS wants to force this book into the school history program.
https://www.amazon.com/Strongman-Extraordinary-Pagoda-Minister-Cambodia/dp/9814361291/ref=sr_1_4?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1499211044&sr=1-4&keywords=hun+sen
Post a Comment